SHERLOCK HOLMES
Holmes would have been borderline to meh if it was not alleviated by Robert Downey Jr's impeccable acting- the slightly zany and extremely logical personality was perfectly embodied. Downey is your ideal modern Sherlock. Watson, his right-hand man, was excellent as well.
I am not aware of how reliable this film is to the original books, for my memory has disposed of mystery novels long ago, but as a movie, it passes my standards. Although a little tedious when Holmes analyzes the moves that he'll inflict on his enemy, the action/violence (LOL) is fair.
All in all this was a good movie, but nothing more.
AVATAR
...in my opinion, was disastrous.
First off, the movie was too long. I lost my interest halfway, and wanted to doze off near the finale. Please, don't ever make 2 hr 40 min movies unless they are pre-approved (BY KORPORATE KAT).
Secondly, the plot was too far-fetched. Before you flame me, I know this is a fantasy/scifi/whatever movie, and of course things will get a little irrational! On the contrary, my mind likes to function logically, and having a battle in which one party has hXc machine guns and explosives, and the other with bows and arrows and some colorful animals who actually WIN is not logical. (E.g. Native Americans vs. European settlers, GER vs. RUS in WWI, IMPERIALISM, etc.) Aiyaiyai.
Thirdly, the villain and the villain's goal was too cliche. It was disappointing.
On the bright side, if you're a fan of fantastic visuals, go for it. Pandora would be breath-taking if you lived in it (esp. by night!).
UP IN THE AIR
Although Up in the Air had superb actors/actresses and very thoughtful meanings/morals, drama on the whole does not appeal to me. I'm sorry, but I cannot stand drama. If I did though, this would be an excellent drama film. The plot is well-contructed and paced, the characters performed beautifully, and for a lot of us, the message of the story is a wake-up call. So yes, I would recommend this IF you like this genre.
Although Up in the Air had superb actors/actresses and very thoughtful meanings/morals, drama on the whole does not appeal to me. I'm sorry, but I cannot stand drama. If I did though, this would be an excellent drama film. The plot is well-contructed and paced, the characters performed beautifully, and for a lot of us, the message of the story is a wake-up call. So yes, I would recommend this IF you like this genre.